France lost 3-1 to Italy on Thursday at San Siro in the Nations League. It is Zinédine Zidane’s first defeat in the competition. After the match he told 20 Minutes: “It’s not a defeat we entirely deserved, we mustn’t panic.”
Silly question, but… can you deserve a defeat a little? I’ve opened a tab in my notebook, between “extra time” and “group in a good place”. It’s called “partial merit”.
I looked for clues. France had 65% of possession and twice as many completed passes as the Italians. Bradley Barcola hit Gianluigi Donnarumma’s post in the 35th minute, Rayan Cherki in the 52nd. So I did a calculation on the 7.32am train: if you have the ball 65% of the time, maybe you deserve 65% of the win? I showed my page to the ticket inspector. He punched my ticket.
Then Andy Diouf said: “We struggled in the second half, we weren’t good in the duels and on the second balls. That’s what made the difference.” And Adrien Rabiot: “We were a bit naive at times.” That lowers my percentage. The weak spell starts in the 55th minute, Italy’s second goal comes in the 63rd. I crossed it out and recalculated.
Basketball doesn’t have that, I looked. The score says who won, and nobody asks whether they entirely deserved it. Here the score stays 3-1, but there’s a conversation around it.
A defeat not entirely deserved, I get three a season. The chairman says he’d deserve them less if the pitch were flat.
I checked, and actually nobody knows how you measure that. France are 2nd in their group behind Italy, on goal difference, and they play Turkey on Sunday in Bordeaux. Anyway, I still have a lot to learn.
It’s true, we checked: 20 Minutes.





